Well I decided to go through that thread - yes, all 177 pages of it - and what's really surprising is that there are actually a few flashes of imagination in there. You've got some people with quite a bit of talent actually and some interesting mecha and fantasy designs and a few interesting gun sketches too. What's
really interesting is that some guy actually tried his hand at some very realistic spaceships:
http://www.alternatehistory.com/discuss ... count=2589
http://www.alternatehistory.com/discuss ... count=2526
http://www.alternatehistory.com/discuss ... count=2513
http://www.alternatehistory.com/discuss ... count=2511
http://www.alternatehistory.com/discuss ... count=2634
http://www.alternatehistory.com/discuss ... count=3522
http://www.alternatehistory.com/discuss ... count=3138
http://www.alternatehistory.com/discuss ... count=3136
http://www.alternatehistory.com/discuss ... count=3034
http://www.alternatehistory.com/discuss ... count=2771
I might make sure that the guy behind the "Atomic Rockets of the Space Patrol" site is made aware of this.
Like I said, actually quite a few flashes of imagination in there, but for the most part, everything is either poorly drawn, outright forgettable, generic, and uninspired, or outright stolen/re-purposed from other sources. Oh, and there are some real gems in there too. These are but a
few that I spotted (and not even the most egregious ones, just ones that I thought were most...interesting)
For the most part they really do speak for themselves, presented without comment, like:
and
and
and
and
Now here's where it gets complex my lovelies:
This fellow wanted basically an improved QEII carrier made from carbon composites, but on top of that he had to add the most
redundant and retarded structure I have yet seen on a carrier minus superfluous gun turrets:
This ship has a few problems here and there, except its biggest one is that it's a
Somali pirate ship
Here's an ELV, and while nothing wrong with it I just look at it and thing "resource sponge":
Here's a land battleship that reminds me of one of those Russian dolls...missiles inside missiles inside missiles....
And I present to you this Jean Bart (yes, it's meant to be the same exact battleship)
and along the same vein, HMS Vanguard
And someone did an illustrated history of the 1949-era battleship USS JUSTICE (really inspiring name there, too). I have to say the style is somewhat...familiar:
Someone saw some of Psilander's ships and requested a NS-type armored cruiser in that style. Unfortunately, the results may make Psilander weep:
Can we say,
epic bad?
Guns? Missiles? Disparate eras?
No problem!
Brought to you by the same person responsible for the Russian Doll Missiles, this is apparently something that belongs in someone's delusional
Halo fanfiction (their admission, not mine) and speaks for itself, except that it's meant to be deployed by
spaceships:
And he also gives us a submarine with thrust-vectoring and
underwater lasers
Oh look he even has ground forces!
And his interpretation of a guided-missile battleship circa 2060:
and a
Halo-era seagoing corvette deployed from space:
This one is actually a nice effort, but still on crack:
And now we finally hit the real noob parade. This one's so good I really have to just quote the backstory on this one:
"The Liberator was developed with one thing in mind: destruction. She was built from the keel up to be able to annihilate enemies on land and sea. The Pentagon decided that American troops were often not given the proper support they needed, and with full-scale war looming over the horizon, she was given the go-ahead in 2014. It took the shipyards at Newport News three years to build her. She was retrofitted in 2022 in preparation for the Brazil-American War, where she bombarded targets as far inland as the Amazonian headwaters.
Originally she was built to be stealthy. Because of this, she has a tumblehome hull and the ability to lower herself into the water through the use of trim tanks. However, the Pentagon later came to the conclusion that stealthiness was unnecessary for the ship they wanted her to be, and so the additional weapons emplacements and RADAR were placed with no thought given to her signature."
Real deep, that was:
Somebody recognized the need for a guided missile battleship and designed appropriately:
To quote the backstory, "this particular ship scored the most kills against Brazilian and Argentinean subs in the Caribbean."
There's some backstory to this one too but it's tl;dr and, well, just take a look:
This poor sod was wondering "what kind of advance program do you use because I just used MSPaint and it's not very good
"
and finally:
I hope this one is a joke.